Score: 7

"It was good."

submission: SDL- Axen Vs. Aurelio

date: February 18, 2009

My one suggestion is that you include the comics that precede the movie in a menu. I have seen other movies from deviantart contests that provided NG viewers the option of reading the comics that came before hand. That orients the viewer so that he or she has a better experience watching your movie.

Score: 6

"Pretty funny."

submission: Obi-Wan's Brilliance

date: January 22, 2009

I liked the idea. Honestly, before I saw this, I thought that you could not possibly make a joke that I have not already heard, but you did. I think that the joke was funny.

That said, the delivery of that joke could have been better all around. The art and animation was crude, but acceptable. The most glaring flaw was in the voice acting. There seemed to be an incredibly annoying static whenever the storm troopers spoke. I know that part of it was a desired effect, but their voices were harsh and unpleasant. The voices of the storm troopers were so jarring that they distracted me from the plot, including the punch line itself. These flaws detracted from the solid humor of the piece.

Overall, I thought this was an entertaining flash movie. If you improve the art, animation and voice acting of your future movies, I am sure that you could make great flashes. Please continue to produce and submit flash movies. Thank you.

Score: 9

"Very good."

submission: Sir D.R.Frostbottom P.I.

date: August 21, 2008

I thought this was a very good movie.

1. I found it to be hilarious. I loved the way you turned Sherlock Holmes on its ear (I read many of those stories when I was young).
2. I liked the voices very much.
3.The animation was very nice. The backgrounds reminded me of Blockhead. How do you make those?
4. I think that Sir Digsby Reginald Frostbottom is a very recognizable and lovable character. I think he could become part of "the gang," just like Pico, Alien Hominid or Bitey.

All in all, I think this would be a great series. I sincerely hope that you do make this into a series. Thank you.

P.S. Do not be discouraged by the fact that this movie has gotten little attention. The first episode of Salad Fingers got virtually no attention and no awards. Now Salad Fingers is one of the best known and most beloved series on Newgrounds.

Score: 5

"Nice."

submission: illwillpenis <3 Clock Day

date: August 16, 2008

Is that Rick Astley I hear? I have a question for illwillpenis: Why are you blue?

Score: 5

"Pretty good."

submission: fighting dude

date: August 15, 2008

Next time, try adding audio, color and a background.

Score: 8

"That was good."

submission: Madness VS Predator 1

date: July 1, 2008

I wish the Predator moved a little more fluidly. It moved unrealistically. If it was more agile, it would have been more entertaining.

Also, when the henchman is thrown out of the window, I think it should have hit the ground before the Kill Count changed. Blood would spatter onto the side of the building, and then the Kill Count would rise.

If I think of anything else, I will PM you.

Score: 0

"Not artsy at all."

submission: guyrttfufyioopöööåöaaaaaa

date: June 9, 2008

A picture of Hugh Laurie's right eye with music is not artsy. It is spam.

Score: 5

"Needs work."

submission: sticky DBZ

date: June 7, 2008

I like the fight sequences and the music. I think you need to put more work into the backgrounds and the attacks. Add some color.

Score: 4

"Sword fight?"

submission: Little Clock Sword Fight

date: May 31, 2008

This is way too slow. It looks more like a slow dance than a sword fight.

Score: 4

"Boring."

submission: Space Cave

date: May 31, 2008

I know this was practice, but it was boring and unoriginal. Keep working. Try a more complex game next time and submit it.